Sole Proprietorship vs LLC: When to Upgrade
If you have any business risk — clients, contracts, inventory, or employees — form an LLC. A sole proprietorship is fine only for ultra-low-risk freelancing where your personal assets aren't at stake. The LLC filing fee ($50–$300) is cheap insurance.
Sole Prop vs LLC: Side-by-Side Comparison
| Category | Sole Prop | LLC |
|---|---|---|
| Liability Protection | None — personal assets at risk | Full personal asset protection |
| Formation Required | No — you're automatically one | Yes — file with your state |
| Formation Cost | $0 (just a business license) | $50–$500 state filing fee |
| Federal Tax Treatment | Schedule C on personal return | Schedule C (single-member) or 1065 (multi) |
| Self-Employment Tax | 15.3% on all net income | 15.3% on all net income |
| Business Bank Account | Optional (but recommended) | Required to maintain liability protection |
| Credibility | Lower — no formal registration | Higher — registered business entity |
| Best For | Ultra-low-risk freelancers, testing ideas | Any business with real risk or growth plans |
Liability Protection
None — personal assets at risk
Full personal asset protection
Formation Required
No — you're automatically one
Yes — file with your state
Formation Cost
$0 (just a business license)
$50–$500 state filing fee
Federal Tax Treatment
Schedule C on personal return
Schedule C (single-member) or 1065 (multi)
Self-Employment Tax
15.3% on all net income
15.3% on all net income
Business Bank Account
Optional (but recommended)
Required to maintain liability protection
Credibility
Lower — no formal registration
Higher — registered business entity
Best For
Ultra-low-risk freelancers, testing ideas
Any business with real risk or growth plans
Liability Protection
This is the single biggest difference. A sole proprietorship provides zero liability protection. If your business gets sued or can't pay its debts, your personal assets — savings, home, car — are all fair game.
An LLC creates a legal wall between your business and personal assets. If the business is sued, only business assets are at risk. Your personal finances stay protected. This alone is worth the $50–$300 filing fee for most businesses.
Tax Treatment
Taxes are essentially identical. A single-member LLC is a "disregarded entity" by default — you report business income on Schedule C of your personal tax return, just like a sole proprietorship.
Self-employment tax (15.3%) applies to all net income in both cases. There's no tax advantage to forming an LLC unless you later elect S-Corp status.
The only tax difference: LLCs in some states pay a franchise tax or annual fee that sole proprietorships don't. California charges $800/year, for example. Check your state before filing.
Formation Process
A sole proprietorship requires no formation — you're automatically a sole proprietor the moment you start doing business. You may need a local business license, but there's no state filing.
Forming an LLC takes 15–30 minutes online. File Articles of Organization with your state's Secretary of State, pay the filing fee, and you're done. Many formation services can do it for free or under $100 plus state fees.
Ongoing Requirements
Sole proprietorships have virtually no ongoing requirements beyond tax filing and any local business license renewals.
LLCs require an annual report in most states ($0–$300/year) and a registered agent ($0–$125/year if you use a service). You should also maintain an operating agreement and keep business finances separate from personal.
Cost Comparison
Sole proprietorships are the cheapest option: $0 to start, $0–$50/year for a business license.
LLCs cost $50–$500 to form (state filing fee) plus $0–$300/year for the annual report. If you use a formation service, add $0–$300 for their fee.
The total cost difference over 3 years is roughly $150–$1,500 depending on your state. That's a small price for personal asset protection.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose Sole Prop if...
- You're testing a business idea with zero financial risk
- You're doing occasional freelance work with no contracts
- You have no business assets, employees, or physical location
- You want absolutely zero startup costs
- Your state has high LLC fees (like California's $800/year)
Choose LLC if...
- You sign contracts with clients or vendors
- You have employees or plan to hire
- You carry inventory, equipment, or business assets
- You want to build business credit separately
- You plan to grow the business or bring on partners
- You work in any field with liability risk (consulting, services, etc.)
Ready to form your LLC?
See your exact formation cost across 11 services — state fees, service fees, and add-ons included.
See Your LLC CostsFree, instant results — no email required
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need an LLC if I'm a freelancer?
It depends on your risk level. If you're a freelance writer working from home, a sole proprietorship is often fine. But if you're a consultant giving business advice, a web developer building apps, or any freelancer signing contracts, an LLC provides important liability protection.
Can I convert a sole proprietorship to an LLC?
Yes. You simply form an LLC with your state. There's no formal "conversion" process. You'll get a new EIN, open a new business bank account, and start operating under the LLC. Any existing contracts should be updated to reference the LLC.
Does an LLC pay less taxes than a sole proprietorship?
Not by default. A single-member LLC is taxed identically to a sole proprietorship. However, LLCs can elect S-Corp taxation (Form 2553) to potentially reduce self-employment taxes when income exceeds $80K/year.
How much does it cost to form an LLC?
State filing fees range from $50 (Kentucky) to $500 (Massachusetts). Most states charge $50–$200. Formation services range from free to $300 on top of state fees. Use our cost estimator to see exact costs for your state.